Specializing in the representation of crime victims, women and children.


By Wendy Murphy    Feb. 04, 2013

Dear Woody;

If you weren’t the umpteenth famous or wealthy guy accused of sexually abusing a child I’d write that I’m outraged and I’d condemn you for being a monster.

But you’re not unusual, sadly. And after decades in this business, I’m tired of being outraged. Which is why I’m writing a different kind of letter to you, Woody.

Allen, Farrow, & FamilyMost men accused of child sex abuse do exactly what you did. They deny the allegations and accuse the child of lying out of spite, or being mentally ill, or they say the child is an innocent victim of a vindictive mother who made the child lie.

In one of your statements you say Dylan’s allegations are false because a seven year-old child cannot be trusted to distinguish between fantasy and reality. This claim makes you look particularly guilty, Woody. See, little girls fantasize about becoming princesses and doctors. They don’t “fantasize” about being told to lie face down and watch a toy train go by while being sexually abused from behind. They have no context to conjure up such a “fantasy.”

Claims that children fantasize about sexual abuse are usually the projected fantasies of guilty perpetrators. Truly innocent guys don’t come up with such an excuse because it never crosses their minds to consider the possibility of any child fantasizing about sexual abuse.

The “fantasy” defense can be effective because it resonates with the public. Most people who never molest children have imagined themselves engaged in some kind of unusual sexual fantasy. They’re open to the possibility that an allegation of odd sexual behavior is a fantasy because it makes them feel “normal” about their own weird urges.

By accusing Dylan of “fantasizing,” Woody, you might succeed in persuading a few people that you did nothing wrong, but most will see such a defense as an admission of guilt. More important, you’ll never overcome your self-loathing and feelings about your own “weird” urges until you accept responsibility for your actions.

I know this is a long shot, but I’m hoping you might have the guts to stand out from the crowd and not only condemn the “fantasy” defense but also use your platform to help others. Think about it. You’ve made a huge mark as a filmmaker. Now’s your chance to really make history.

You don’t have to explain why you did what you did, and you don’t have to offer up any details. It’s enough to acknowledge the truth of one little girl.

I’m sure you once loved Dylan, Woody, and I know you understand love because so many of your films deal with its power.

In Midnight in Paris, you wrote dialogue for Ernest Hemingway that no doubt reveals something inside of you:

“All cowardice comes from loving, or not loving well, which is the same thing.”

Don’t be a coward, Woody. You’ve written extraordinary dialogue for some of film’s most interesting characters. Be brave enough now to write the most profound words of your storied career:

“I’m sorry.”

Wendy Murphy

New England Law|Boston

Back to top of page.